Dynasty Trade CalculatorCheck a trade

Guide

KeepTradeCut vs FantasyCalc

By Dynasty Trade Calculator editorial team · Published 15 November 2026

KeepTradeCut builds values from crowd votes, where managers rank three players at a time, and blends in real trades. FantasyCalc builds values only from real completed trades, solved by an optimization algorithm. Both were free when checked on 15 November 2026. Pick KeepTradeCut for fast crowd sentiment and FantasyCalc for prices based on deals that closed.

Key takeaways

  • KeepTradeCut prices crowd votes. FantasyCalc prices completed trades.
  • Both were free when checked on 15 November 2026. Check the site for current access.
  • Scales differ, so compare ranks and gaps, not raw numbers.
  • This site uses neither tool's data and is not affiliated with either.

Independence note: Dynasty Trade Calculator is independent and not affiliated with KeepTradeCut or FantasyCalc. This guide describes both tools from public pages checked on 15 November 2026. It copies no values from either tool, and it states where a fact could not be verified.

How does KeepTradeCut build its values?

KeepTradeCut builds values from crowd votes. Managers rank three players at a time as Keep, Trade, or Cut, and an adapted Elo system turns the votes into values on a 0 to 10,000 scale. The site reports more than 26 million data points, and rankings refresh every 10 minutes, as observed on 15 November 2026.

KeepTradeCut also offers Tradesourced values, built from real trades, and a Crowd plus Trade blend. Its FAQ instructs users to answer in a vacuum, on raw value alone. The site is free and accepts donations, and it asks each visitor one Keep, Trade, Cut question per visit.

The base format is fixed at 12 teams and half PPR, with separate databases for Superflex and 1QB, and TE premium tiers from Off to TE+++. Pick coverage runs from exact current-year slots, 1.01 to 4.12, to Early, Mid, and Late ranges for future rounds. A separate devy database, startup values to 43.12, and a Liquidity Score from the latest 25,000 real trades, standardized from 1 to 99 with picks excluded, round out the tool. League sync covers MyFantasyLeague, Sleeper, FFPC, Fleaflicker, and Fantrax, per the site FAQ.

How does FantasyCalc build its values?

FantasyCalc builds values only from real completed trades. An optimization algorithm solves individual player values from millions of deals managers closed, then adjusts the values to league settings. Its homepage showed 8,479,339 trades on 15 November 2026, with updates several times per day.

Its homepage claims updates every 3 hours all season. A trade database of more than 2 million searchable deals backs the values with evidence. Settings cover 8 to 14 teams, PPR, half PPR, and standard scoring, plus 1QB and 2QB-Superflex formats. A TE premium adjustment is described on the site; check the site for the current controls.

The scale runs above 10,000. Its Superflex dynasty table showed Josh Allen at 11,042 on 15 November 2026. Pick coverage lists exact 2026 slots and round-only 2027 to 2028 picks, per the Apex comparison of trade tools. Its league analyzer page names Sleeper, ESPN, MyFantasyLeague, Fleaflicker, and FFPC, but whether each one links to the calculator itself was not settled in the sources checked, so check the site. No paywall was found when checked on 15 November 2026.

Where do the two tools disagree most?

The two tools disagree most on scale, speed, and picks. KeepTradeCut scores run 0 to 10,000, while FantasyCalc scores run past 10,000, so raw numbers never compare directly. Crowd votes move in minutes, while trade data lags news. KeepTradeCut ranks picks higher than other sources, by its own comparison.

KeepTradeCut and FantasyCalc compared
AspectKeepTradeCutFantasyCalc
InputCrowd votes, plus real tradesReal completed trades
Scale0 to 10,000Past 10,000
RefreshEvery 10 minutesSeveral times per day
Base format12-team half PPR, fixedSettings-adjusted
Cost, checked 15 Nov 2026Free, donations acceptedFree, no paywall found

Each blind spot follows its input. Crowd votes react fast and can overshoot when hype runs hot. Trade data shows prices paid, but it lags breaking news and thins out for players who rarely change teams. A fixed base format misleads leagues with different scoring, while a settings-adjusted board still needs the right settings entered. Compare ranks and gaps across tools, never raw numbers.

Crowd votes tell you what managers feel. Completed trades tell you what managers paid.

Which tool should you use for your league?

Use KeepTradeCut when you need fast crowd sentiment, startup depth, or a devy board, and when your leaguemates speak its language. Use FantasyCalc when you want prices from deals that closed, matched to your league settings. Use both when a deal is close, since disagreement between the two is useful information on its own.

DynastyFootballTradeCalculator notes that many experienced managers use two sources, and that disagreement between sources is itself useful information. OfficePoolStop describes KeepTradeCut as the shared language of leagues, a common currency for trade talks. A tool your leaguemates trust settles arguments faster than a tool only you trust.

Both tools were free when checked on 15 November 2026. Gates change, so check the site for current access before you plan around either tool. The comparison page lists more tools with the same check date.

How does this site differ from both?

This site differs by using neither tool's data and publishing its own method. Its values are editorial estimates set from public reporting, not transaction data. Its rule is fixed and printed: stud weights of 100, 75, 55, 40, 30, then 20 percent, a fair band of 5 percent, and a gap measured against the larger total.

The split is deliberate. KeepTradeCut's Terms forbid scraping, data mining, and reuse of its data on another site, and its FAQ states it offers no API or CSV file. No FantasyCalc terms text permitting reuse was found in research on 15 November 2026, so reuse stays unresolved. This site cites single values with credit in guides, as KeepTradeCut encourages, and copies no board from either tool. The data sources page lists every input and its status.

Entry is manual, so the calculator works for any platform, with no league link claimed and no account needed. The methodology page prints the full rule, and the disagreement guide explains why tools split. This site is independent and not affiliated with KeepTradeCut or FantasyCalc.

A fast answer and a proven answer are not the same answer. Use both, and know which one you are reading.

What else should you know about KeepTradeCut and FantasyCalc?

These answers cover cost, scales, and this site's data stance, as verified on 15 November 2026. Check either site for current access.

Is KeepTradeCut free?

Yes, with a vote gate. KeepTradeCut is free to use and accepts donations, and it asks each visitor to answer one Keep, Trade, Cut question per visit before using the tools. That vote is the price of entry, and it feeds the crowd data. Check the site for current access, since gates can change.

Is FantasyCalc free?

Yes, as checked on 15 November 2026. No paywall was found on its calculator or league tools, and its pages present it as a hobby project. Free tools change their gates over time, so check the site for current access before you plan around it. This guide states only what was observed on the check date.

Why is the same player worth more on one tool?

The tools use different scales and different inputs. KeepTradeCut scores players from 0 to 10,000 by crowd votes. FantasyCalc scores run above 10,000, built from completed trades. A higher number on FantasyCalc does not mean the player is worth more. It means the ruler is longer, so compare ranks and gaps, not raw numbers, across tools.

Does this site copy values from KeepTradeCut or FantasyCalc?

No. This site uses neither tool's data. KeepTradeCut's Terms forbid scraping and reuse of its data on another site, and no reuse permission was found for FantasyCalc. This site runs its own editorial board, set by its editors from public reporting, and its method is published on the methodology page. It is independent and not affiliated with either tool.

What should you read next?

Three guides pick up where this one ends: split verdicts, what each number prices, and the fair band. Read the one that matches your next decision.