Dynasty Trade CalculatorCheck a trade

The method, in full

Dynasty Trade Calculator Methodology

This page states the full rule behind every verdict on this site. Values run on a 0 to 10,000 scale. Each side gets a raw total and a stud-weighted adjusted total. The gap between adjusted totals, divided by the larger total, decides the verdict. No hidden step changes the result.

A Methodology link sits in the header and footer on every page, and the value chart pages link here too, so the rule is one click from any verdict.

The scale

What scale do values use?

Values run on a 0 to 10,000 scale. The best assets sit near 10,000. Role players sit far below them. A value of 5,000 means half the top of the scale, not half the worth of a top player in a real league. The scale is a yardstick, not a price tag.

Many dynasty tools use the same 0 to 10,000 scale. That makes numbers easy to compare at a glance. It does not make them equal. A 9,000 on this site comes from this site's board and this site's rules. A 9,000 on another tool comes from that tool's source and method. Read the method before you compare numbers across tools.

The board behind the scale is an editorial board. It holds 320 players plus 48 rookie picks, with values set by the site editors from public reporting. Every surface that shows these numbers carries a badge stating the update date. The data sources page states what the board is, what it is not, and which routes were ruled out.

Side totals

How is each side scored?

Each side gets two totals. The raw total is simple addition: add every piece value on the side. The adjusted total applies stud weights: pieces are ranked high to low, and each rank keeps only its weight. The verdict uses the adjusted totals. Both totals stay visible, so you can see what the weights changed.

The weights are fixed. They come from the calculator code, quoted here exactly: STUD_WEIGHTS = [1.0, 0.75, 0.55, 0.4, 0.3], then 0.2 for the 6th piece and each piece after it.

Stud weights by piece rank, highest piece first
Piece rankWeight kept
Best piece100%
2nd piece75%
3rd piece55%
4th piece40%
5th piece30%
6th piece and later20%

Why weight pieces at all? A roster spot has a cost. Twelve bench players do not help a starting lineup the way one star does, even when their raw sum matches. The weights price that fact. The best piece keeps full value. Each extra piece counts less. A trade of one star for three mid pieces must clear the weights. The raw sum alone is not enough.

The gap

How is the gap measured?

The gap is the difference between the two adjusted totals, divided by the larger total, times 100. The larger total is the base, so the gap can never pass 100 percent. Two empty sides give a gap of 0.

Verdict bands by adjusted gap percent
GapVerdict
0 to 5%Fair
Over 5% to 15%Edge to the leading side
Over 15%Win for the leading side

The calculator prints the gap to one decimal place, with a short sentence. A fair verdict reads "Fair trade. Gap: 3.2%." An edge reads "Side A has the edge. Gap: 8.4%." A win reads "Side A wins on value. Gap: 22.1%." The side named is the side with the larger adjusted total.

The 5 percent and 15 percent lines are site rules, published here. Other tools use other bands. RotoBaller, for example, calls 0 to 5 percent a great trade and 6 to 15 percent a fair deal. Bands differ. The gap number is what travels across tools. Judge the gap, not the label alone.

Format rules

How do format, scoring, and TE premium change values?

Format comes first. Pick the wrong format and every value that follows is wrong for your league. Quarterbacks carry two values: one for Superflex and one for 1QB. The gap between formats is too large for one number, so the board stores both. Other positions use one value in both formats. That is a stated limit of the current board, not a hidden detail.

Scoring starts from half PPR. Full PPR and standard scoring apply fixed multipliers to pass catchers. Quarterback values do not move with scoring.

Scoring multipliers by position, base is half PPR
ScoringWR and TERBQB
Half PPR (base)x1.00x1.00No change
Full PPRx1.05x1.03No change
Standardx0.95x0.97No change

TE premium lifts tight ends only. Plus 0.5 uses x1.10. Plus 1.0 uses x1.20. No other position moves. Picks do not move with format, scoring, or TE premium. A pick value is the same in every setting. Player values round to whole numbers after the multipliers apply.

The calculator prints the exact rules behind each verdict, in one line. The format pages state the same rules for their preset: the Superflex calculator, the 1QB calculator, and the TE premium calculator.

Picks

How are rookie picks valued?

Current-year picks use exact slots, because the draft order is known. This board lists 2027 picks from 1.01 through 2.12. Future picks use Early, Mid, and Late ranges, because the exact slot is still unknown. This board lists 2028 and 2029 picks in rounds 1 through 4, in each range.

A future first round pick drops about 10 percent for each year you wait. That discount is a site rule, stated here. It reflects the wait and the unknown class. Pick slots assume a 12-team league. The calculator does not adjust pick values for league size. That is a stated limit.

The full ladder lives on the rookie pick values page, with the same badge and the same discount rule.

Suggestions

How do even-trade suggestions work?

When a trade is lopsided, the calculator suggests single adds that would close the gap. The rule is plain. Both sides must hold at least one piece. The gap must be over 5 percent. A fair trade needs no fix, so no suggestions appear.

Each unused piece is tried on the losing side, one at a time. The side is re-ranked high to low, and the stud weights apply exactly as they do when the piece joins the trade. A piece counts only if it shrinks the gap. Pieces already in the trade are never suggested.

Suggestions rank by resulting gap, smallest first. The closest fit to even wins. If two pieces land on the same gap, the smaller add ranks first. At most three suggestions appear. A suggestion is a starting point for a counter-offer. It is not advice to trade for that player. Your roster needs and your window still decide the deal.

Worked example

Can you check a verdict by hand?

Yes. The worked example below uses example values, with Superflex, half PPR, and no TE premium. Side A gives Josh Allen (9,900). Side B gives George Kittle (4,600), a 2027 2.06 pick (4,000), and Derrick Henry (3,800).

Side B wins the raw total, 12,400 to 9,900. The stud weights cut Side B to 4,600 plus 3,000 plus 2,090, which is 9,690. Side A keeps 9,900. The gap is 210 on the larger total of 9,900, which is 2.1 percent. Fair.

Try the same trade in the calculator on the home page. It applies the same rule to the live board. If a verdict looks wrong for the values shown, that is a bug, and the contact page is the route to report it.

Freshness

How often do values update?

The board updates weekly during the season. Major news that moves a top player calls for a same-day change. Each update carries a visible date, and the badge on each value surface states the current update date. Freshness dates change only when values change.

The offseason pace is slower, with faster updates around free agency and the NFL Draft. Each update carries a visible date on the value pages, so you can see when the board last changed. The data sources page states what the board is and how it is set.

Limits

What are the limits of this method?

Values are estimates, not prices. No formula sees your roster, your starting lineup needs, or what your leaguemates will pay this week. A fair trade can still be wrong for a team that gives away its only starting quarterback. A lopsided trade on paper can still make sense when a contender buys the last starter for a title run.

The calculator prices trades in a vacuum. It has no contender or rebuilder adjustment. It does not adjust for league size. It covers offense only: no IDP, no devy, and no startup mode. Only quarterbacks carry two native format values. Other positions use fixed multipliers.

Use the verdict as a check, then judge fit. Does this trade help your team win in your window, at a price your league would pay? If the answer is no, walk away, even when the gap reads fair. The disclaimer page states the full limits.

Changelog

Methodology changelog

This log gains a new row each time the formula or the board changes. Dates are not touched without a real change.

Methodology changes by date
DateChange
November 15, 2026Site rebuild. Formula published on this page: 0 to 10,000 scale, stud weights, 5 percent fair band, gap on the larger total. No earlier formula exists for this site.
November 17, 2026Editorial board published: 320 players plus 48 rookie picks, with values set by the site editors from public reporting. Games through Week 10, including the Monday night game of November 16, 2026. The badge on each value surface states the update date.